Equal Exchange vs. Amazon Fresh: Breakfast Coffee Battle
When it comes to starting your day with a great cup of coffee, the choices can be overwhelming. Two popular options that often come up are Equal Exchange Breakfast Coffee and Amazon Fresh Sumatra Coffee. Each offers a unique flavor profile and sourcing philosophy, making them appealing to different preferences and values. In this comparison, you’ll discover what sets these two coffees apart, from their taste and aroma to their ethical considerations and availability. Let’s dive in and explore how they stack up against each other.
Morning Boost

Equal Exchange Organic Ground Coffee offers a delicious Breakfast Blend with a sweet, balanced flavor profile, featuring hints of chocolate brownie, roasted nut, and caramel. This 12-ounce bag contains 100% Fair Trade, certified organic Arabica coffee sustainably sourced from small-scale farmer cooperatives around the world.
Morning Boost

Experience the rich, intense flavor of Amazon Fresh Organic Fair Trade Sumatra Ground Coffee, a dark roast made from 100% Arabica beans. This 12-ounce bag is USDA Organic and Fair Trade certified, ensuring both quality and ethical sourcing.
Equal Exchange Breakfast Coffee
Roast Type
Balanced Medium & French Roast Blend
Flavor Profile
Sweet classic coffee blend with hints of chocolate brownie, roasted nut & caramel
Origin of Coffee Beans
Sustainably grown by small-scale farmer cooperatives in Latin America, Africa & Asia
Certifications
100% Fair Trade, Certified Organic by the USDA, Certified Kosher
Packaging
12 oz bag, single pack
Amazon Fresh Sumatra Coffee
Roast Type
Dark Roast with deep, intense flavor
Flavor Profile
Intense flavor characteristic of dark roast coffee
Origin of Coffee Beans
Grown specifically in Sumatra
Certifications
Fair Trade certified, USDA Organic
Packaging
12 oz bag, single pack, roasted and packed in the U.S.A.
Equal Exchange Breakfast Coffee
Amazon Fresh Sumatra Coffee
Equal Exchange Breakfast Coffee
Amazon Fresh Sumatra Coffee
Comparison table


Unique Selling Points (USPs)
Equal Exchange Organic Ground Coffee
- Fair Trade Impact: Supports small farmers and promotes sustainable practices.
- Flavor Diversity: Offers a balanced flavor profile suitable for various palates.
- Ethical Sourcing: Committed to social and environmental responsibility.
Amazon Fresh Organic Fair Trade Sumatra Ground Coffee
- Robust Flavor: Perfect for those who enjoy a strong, dark coffee experience.
- Affordability: Competitive pricing without compromising on quality.
- Convenience: Easily available through Amazon with quick shipping options.
Similarities
- Both coffees are USDA Organic and Fair Trade Certified, ensuring quality and ethical sourcing.
- Each is available in a 12-ounce package, making them comparable in size.
- Both brands prioritize sustainability and support for farmers.
Pros and Cons
Equal Exchange Organic Ground Coffee
Pros:
- Great for those who enjoy a smooth, medium roast.
- Supports fair trade practices, benefiting farmers directly.
- Versatile for various brewing methods.
Cons:
- Slightly higher price point compared to budget options.
- May not satisfy those who prefer a stronger, darker coffee.
Amazon Fresh Organic Fair Trade Sumatra Ground Coffee
Pros:
- Bold flavor that appeals to dark roast lovers.
- Often at a lower price point, making it budget-friendly.
- Conveniently available through Amazon.
Cons:
- May be too strong for those who prefer milder coffee.
- Limited flavor profile compared to more diverse blends.
Use Cases
- Equal Exchange: Ideal for casual coffee drinkers and those who appreciate a balanced cup. Perfect for morning routines or casual gatherings.
- Amazon Fresh Sumatra: Best suited for coffee aficionados who enjoy a rich, dark brew, especially for those who prefer espresso or stronger flavors.
Conclusive Assessment
There is no absolute winner in this comparison, as each product excels in different areas. Equal Exchange Organic Ground Coffee is the choice for consumers looking for a balanced and ethically sourced coffee experience. On the other hand, Amazon Fresh Organic Fair Trade Sumatra Ground Coffee is a conditional winner for those seeking a bold flavor at an economical price.
Final Summary
In summary, if you’re looking for a smooth, ethically sourced coffee that supports farmers, go with Equal Exchange Organic Ground Coffee. However, if you prefer a robust, dark roast at a budget-friendly price, Amazon Fresh Organic Fair Trade Sumatra Ground Coffee is your best bet. Your choice ultimately depends on your flavor preference and the importance you place on ethical sourcing versus cost.


Exploring Ethical Choices Beyond Traditional Coffee

General Guidelines for Comparing Fair Trade Coffee Products
When it comes to selecting Fair Trade coffee, it’s essential to make informed decisions that align with your values and taste preferences. Here are some guidelines and key factors to consider when comparing products like ‘Equal Exchange Breakfast Coffee’ and ‘Amazon Fresh Sumatra Coffee’.
1. Understand Fair Trade Certification
Before diving into comparisons, it’s crucial to know what Fair Trade certification means. This certification ensures that the coffee is produced under fair labor conditions and that farmers receive a fair price for their beans.
- Ethical Practices: Fair Trade promotes sustainable farming practices.
- Fair Pricing: Farmers are paid a minimum price that covers their costs.
- Community Development: Fair Trade profits often fund community projects.
2. Origin of the Coffee
The origin can influence both flavor and the ethical implications of the coffee.
- Single-Origin vs. Blend: Single-origin coffees like Sumatra often have distinct flavor profiles, while blends may offer a balanced taste.
- Sourcing Practices: Investigate how the coffee is sourced and if it supports local farmers.
3. Flavor Profile
Flavor is subjective, but understanding the notes and characteristics can help you choose coffee that suits your palate.
- Taste Notes: Check for descriptions of flavor notes (e.g., fruity, nutty, chocolatey).
- Roast Level: Light, medium, and dark roasts have different flavor profiles; consider what you prefer.
4. Packaging and Sustainability
Packaging can impact the environment, so look for eco-friendly options.
- Recyclable or Compostable Packaging: Consider brands that prioritize sustainable packaging.
- Bulk Options: Buying in bulk can reduce packaging waste.
5. Price Point
While price isn’t everything, it can reflect quality and sourcing practices.
- Cost vs. Quality: Higher price points often indicate better quality and ethical sourcing.
- Value for Money: Consider how much coffee you get for the price and the potential benefits of supporting Fair Trade.
6. Brand Reputation
Research the brand’s reputation in the Fair Trade community.
- Transparency: Look for brands that are open about their sourcing and production processes.
- Customer Reviews: Check online reviews and ratings to gauge customer satisfaction.
7. Additional Attributes
Some coffees come with extra features that might appeal to you.
- Organic Certification: Some Fair Trade coffees are also organic, which can be a plus for health-conscious consumers.
- Flavor Variety: Consider whether the brand offers different flavors or seasonal blends.
Understanding Fair Trade Coffee: Key Questions Answered
When comparing Equal Exchange Organic Ground Coffee, Breakfast Blend, and Amazon Fresh Organic Fair Trade Sumatra Ground Coffee, there are a few key differences to consider:
- Source and Sourcing Practices:
- Equal Exchange specializes in fair trade products and emphasizes direct relationships with small-scale farmers. Their coffee is sourced in a way that supports sustainable farming practices and empowers farmers economically.
- Amazon Fresh offers a fair trade option with their Sumatra coffee but is primarily a retail brand under Amazon. While they promote fair trade practices, the direct farmer relationships may not be as emphasized as with Equal Exchange.
- Blend and Flavor Profile:
- Equal Exchange Breakfast Blend is typically a light to medium roast, designed to be smooth and balanced, making it a versatile choice for various brewing methods.
- Amazon Fresh Sumatra Dark Roast is a dark roast, which generally has a bolder, richer flavor profile with earthy and chocolatey notes, appealing to those who prefer a strong cup of coffee.
- Organic Certification:
- Both coffees are organic, but Equal Exchange is well-known for its commitment to organic farming practices, which are closely tied to their fair trade model.
- Amazon Fresh also offers organic certification but primarily focuses on a broader range of products without the same level of emphasis on direct farmer relationships.
- Brand Philosophy:
- Equal Exchange has a strong focus on social justice, sustainability, and community support, which is reflected in their overall mission.
- Amazon Fresh, being part of a larger corporate structure, focuses on convenience and affordability, often appealing to a wider market.
In summary, if you’re looking for a coffee that aligns closely with social justice and direct farmer support, Equal Exchange might be your best choice. If you prefer a bold dark roast and the convenience of an online shopping experience, Amazon Fresh could be more suitable for you.
Further Reading: Amazon Fresh Decaf Coffee vs. Peet's Decaf Major Dickason's. Please visit REVIEWS to check out more similar articles.
Can anyone recommend a good decaf version of these? Need something for evenings!
I hear you! Decaf can be tricky. Maybe check out Equal Exchange’s Decaf option; I’ve heard good things.
Thanks for this comparison! I didn’t realize there were so many differences between these coffees. Really helpful!
You’re welcome! I’m glad you found it useful. There’s so much to explore in the coffee world!
Great suggestion! Peet’s and Stumptown have some strong followers—I’ll consider adding them in the future.
Honestly, I prefer Amazon Fresh over Equal Exchange. I find it a bit stronger and richer in flavor. Anyone else feel this way?
Interesting take! Coffee preferences are super subjective—everyone has their own taste buds!
Fair trade coffee is awesome! Make sure to check the certification on the packaging; it really makes a difference for farmers!
Absolutely! Knowing where your coffee comes from is so important, and fair trade helps ensure that farmers get a fair shake.
I recently switched to Fair Trade coffee, and I feel great about supporting those farmers. Plus, it tastes amazing!
That’s fantastic! The quality can really be noticeable, and it feels good to support ethical practices.
I’d love to see a comparison with Peet’s Coffee or Stumptown! Those are my go-tos.
I tried Equal Exchange Breakfast Coffee last week, and wow, it was smooth! Definitely my fave.
So glad to hear you enjoyed it! It’s been a hit for a lot of coffee lovers.
If you’re looking for a solid medium roast, I recommend trying Lavazza! It’s not Fair Trade, but it’s super flavorful.
Thanks for the recommendation! Lavazza does have a great reputation for quality, even if it’s not Fair Trade.